Skip to main content

Challenging or Competent?

For a VCO (Volunteer Community Orchestra), is it better to choose music that is challenging or that your musicians can play competently?
          If you look at the programs from American professional orchestras in the major cities (the ones with NFL teams), you see the glory years of symphonic composition covered quite well. Hit the high points – Germany and surrounding areas gave us Mozart, Schubert, Mendelssohn, Beethoven, Brahms, and many more. Russia throws in Tchaikovsky, Rimsky-Korsakov, Rachmaninoff, and the rest of that gang, France washes us in color from Debussy and Ravel, other countries pitch in with Sibelius, Elgar, Copland, etc.
          FYI – in the 2016-2016 concert season, more American orchestras performed the Beethoven No. 3, Eroica, than any other symphony (thanks, BaltimoreSymphony Orchestra).
          Should the suburban VCO play the same music as the local professional orchestra staffed by full-time paid musicians? Whether or not they should, they do, season in and season out. VCO quality varies from amateur to amazing, of course, but this comparison does seem like putting the kid who sang in high school choir onstage between Adele and Beyonce.
          The detail that's most confusing to me? How much audience overlap is there between your average VCO and the "Big Symphony" downtown? In my area, I would be amazed if it's more than 20 percent, and that's generous. But my VCO has no audience data that shows this information that I have seen. So if we don't play those big name pieces, our audience probably won't hear them played live elsewhere.
          Another confusing detail for me: is a Great Symphony play poorly better than an easier symphony played well? Which helps the players and audience more? How do we find that balance? If you have an answer, please comment.
          My concern is whether programming the Schubert 8th is a copout and shows a lack of courage on my part. Or it that piece a well-considered choice based on the attendance and capabilities of the orchestra for the first concert of the year?
          After chewing on this topic far too many nights, I think building up to the great pieces makes the most sense for my VCO. Shubert 8th in the first concert would, if I was leading the group (fingers crossed), build up to the Dvorak 8th in the last concert.
Does that make sense to you, based on your local music scene? 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Can't Finish with the Unfinished

Photo courtesy: Unsplash.com After much consideration, and conversations with people interested in helping me present the best concert possible, I have come to the conclusion I can't finish my concert with the Unfinished Symphony. The concern? If we play it beautifully, the soft ending relaxes people too much for them to get excited about the wonderful concert. We don’t want to hear the last chord float through the hall and the listeners all sigh contentedly. We want them to scream with excitement.           The concert is labeled," Classic with a Twist." Perhaps the twist is we play the symphony in the first half, and the Handel Water Music as the closer. Lots of brass in the Hornpipe that finishes the Hamilton Hardy arrangement of the Water Music, and that should help pull people up out of their seats and get them cheering at the end.           Beautiful endings CAN pull people out o...
Post a Comment
Read more

Picking My Program – The Big Piece

For the final audition in our selection process, each of the three conductors gets to rehearse and perform one concert. Each finalist chooses his (no hers involved, unfortunately) own program, based on a theme. Mine is “Classical with a Twist.” Not sure what that means.           The interim conductor, who unfortunately has the inside track on the final job here as in all other interim situations, will do the Christmas concert. This is another big advantage for the candidate let’s call T. We do two performances of the Christmas concert to accommodate all the attendees, since our hall is rather small. Good, but small. The other finalist, let’s call him M, will do the November concert.           I get the September concert, the first of the year. Good in that I can make the first impression and set the bar for the others, and bad in that ramping up is a slow process that makes for some sparse re...
Post a Comment
Read more

Welcome to The Unstuffy Symphony

OK, here's the deal: I want to make my volunteer community orchestra as “unstuffy” as possible. Technically, the orchestra is not mine, at least not yet. I am one of three finalists to become conductor of a community orchestra in a suburb of one of the three major cities in Texas. But those details are for later.    I can tell you the truth because I'm hiding behind a layer of anonymity. After the audition process, if I get the honor of being appointed the new conductor, I will put my name on this and continue. If not, I may scuttle it but will more likely keep it anonymous as I try to make changes after somehow getting on the Board of Directors and start pushing for change from the inside.     What do I mean by an "unstuffy" symphony orchestra? Classical music of all kinds gets accused of being stuffy, pretentious, and elitist. Often those criticisms are warranted, at least about practitioners if not the music itself. At the community level, the 1,400 to 1,700 ...
Post a Comment
Read more